204 Comments
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Saw this over the weekend, it's a review of videos produced by cults (like recruitment videos from Aum Shinrikyo) and it had a bit about the Sedevacantists, whose offering was a catchy banjo-pickin' country tune about how they still don't eat meat on Fridays, and I briefly thought, "Aw, these folks don't seem so bad!" and THEN THEY GOT TO THE JEWS.

https://youtu.be/Vo-OlxINoJI

Expand full comment

This seems to link to a video about hoodie pockets.

Expand full comment

Although now I'm expecting a lil' kickback from the hoody pockets people.

Expand full comment

Turn around, bend over. I got a long line of volunteers here...

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

"pre-verbal ululations" or "Ian Killjew" one of those is the best thing ever. Maybe both! I can't decide. And am I lucky to have choices like this?

Of course I am.

Great column!

Expand full comment
author

Glad I caught you in a good mood!

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Well, dark humor is

nonetheless humor and like Art Linkletter used to say - Humor is the best medicine!

Maybe that was Bennet Cerf.*

Art Linkletter said, when questioned by the authorities,

" Kids say the darndest things!"

* I still don't know. Is it "surf"

at the beach or " kerf" like the width of a saw blade ? I guess if I really cared I could Google it.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

I always pronounced it to rhyme with "surf"

Expand full comment

Cerf’s up!

Expand full comment

Definitely with a soft C. I didn't stay home sick from elementary school watching "What's My Line" for nothing.

Expand full comment

Wait. You got PAID??!!

Expand full comment

with knowledge

Expand full comment

I know his son. It's "surf."

Expand full comment

Died in 1971 when JK Rowling was only 6, so we were spared Cerf & TERF

Expand full comment

On What's My Line, Jon Daly always pronounced it surf

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

"it’s important to be generally tolerant of intellectuals who may hold some immoral views"

But of course we can't be tolerant of the alphabet people, nosirree, that's going Too Far.

Fuck you, Rod.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Rod was just as shocked to learn about Hanania as he was to learn his own Dad was in the KKK or to learn the headmaster of his kids' school was a Nazi. Shocked, shocked I tell you.

Someone should really ask Dreher: as he is so easily duped and undiscerning, why should people pay attention to anything he says about any topic? (not that any sensible person does)

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Well, anyone the left doesn't like is a NAZI, you know, hard to tell with all that going on! (I just cut to the chase & call 'em fascists, though Falangists is probably more apt but who'd get the reference?)

Expand full comment

Urgent oo, ooing sounds from the back of the room, hand raised and waving..."pick me!"

Expand full comment

Well, that's cheating, because I know everyone here will get it.

Expand full comment

Well, I know you need a ga-gasket for that falange.

Expand full comment

Although Webster seems to think they are the same thing.

Expand full comment

The fascists never had a world class flamenco guitarist on their team. The Falange, on the other hand...

Expand full comment

That was because of the falanges aka fingers

Expand full comment

Weird, innit? Like how all the people Donald Trump hired as President turned out to be deep-state operatives who wanted to destroy America! What're the odds, huh?

Expand full comment

If you can’t spot the Nazi at a Nazi rally, perhaps you too are a Nazi.

Expand full comment

It's just too bad for President Trump that he didn't have any previous experience evaluating a group of people and deciding which ones were good and which ones were losers. Could have come in handy when he was picking an Attorney General.

Expand full comment

So, discernment-challenged?

Expand full comment

All the best people weren’t.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Cmon Roy, don’t leave us hanging! Which immoral view could he mean???

Expand full comment

For a while Sully said nice things about the 5th Column left

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

[goose holding knife in its beak] Which views? Which views, motherfucker?

Expand full comment

Knife-wielding Goose meets Milkshake Duck.

Expand full comment

Generally tolerant of intellectuals who may hold some immoral views. Provided, of course, that those views are not "we should feed the hungry, clothe the naked, house the homeless, heal the sick"--you know, any of those things that Jesus said we should be doing. Those things are a level of immorality that is simply unforgivable.

And provided those views are not "we probably shouldn't be beating homosexuals to death." And we can't accept "summary execution of Black people simply for being Black is not a good thing."

But "we should do the Holocaust right this time!" is definitely a view we need to be tolerant about because the intellectual promoting may have some other ideas.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

"So much for the tolerant Left!!!"

Expand full comment

I may be overstating things, but the "slavery taught skills" makes me think of the "they're learning how to have a job" bullshit of Workfare. Nowhere near equivalent but I get echoes.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023

Oh, absolutely. And let's remember these are lessons being directed at children. Because it's important to inspire children with the message that in America, absolutely anyone, if they work hard, can obtain employment as a manual laborer or perhaps even in a skilled trade where they might be able to earn enough to pay rent.

Expand full comment

And maybe even before they get out of elementary school! 😖

Expand full comment

Whoa, I don't know if I can handle that much inspiration.

Expand full comment

Don't forget the ability to enlist in the military to have exotic adventures and create profit for our proud "defense" industry.

Expand full comment

I was just reading a review of the movie From Here to Eternity which is enjoying a 70th anniversary and it mentions that in the original novel, Frank Sinatra's character, Maggio, performs oral sex on older men for money because he can't live on Army pay.

Expand full comment

Time for a remake, m'thinks.

Expand full comment

Reich-To-Work State

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023

Because being intellectual, having intellectual-seeming thoughts, is such a rare thing that we basically have to accept anyone even willing to try. You know, like if you had some rare brain tumor and the only doctor capable of removing it was Josef Megele.

Myself, I feel like we're adequately supplied with public intellectuals and can afford to be a little choosy.

Expand full comment

"it’s important to be generally tolerant of intellectuals who may hold some immoral views" as long as some of their views agree with mine

Expand full comment

Maybe it should read "specifically tolerant" instead.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

The Tulsa Massacre? Really? I hadn’t realized in condemning the mass murder of an entire community, we were voicing a “slanted perspective on American history.”

The only viewpoints the Right and Center-Right DON’T find interesting and compelling enough to engage with are any viewpoints that promote egalitarianism and acknowledge the full rights and humanity of everyone. They always regard those ideas as commie trash that is beyond the pale.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Well, you know, "urban blight" 🙄 funny though how the Bad Parts of Town always mirror where there was redlining for decades.

Expand full comment

One of the things that mystifies me is when the braying asses known as the GOP claim that the liberal commie Marxist socialist Democrat Party has ruined the country. I’d go farther than your point above: the regressive reactionary fascist Nazi GOP believes that to promote egalitarianism and acknowledge the full rights and humanity of everyone is what is destroying America, i.e., the America that exists in right wing propaganda.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Stuff doesn't look like it used to! Things change! Waaah, we're gonna have to civil war if things don't change back!

Expand full comment

There are miscegenating couples in advertisements

Expand full comment

Have you noticed now that when you say "Thank you" people say "No problem" instead of "You're welcome"? I blame the Democrats.

Expand full comment

No problemo

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

I agree.

Expand full comment

Yeah, we just gotta vote for whoever the Republicans nominate, even Trump, because four more years of Biden/Harris is just unthinkable! Just look at how much they've destroyed America in the three years they've had already!

Expand full comment

They let a million people die for nothing!

Oh, wait, that was the previous guy.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Why even bring up slavery? Such an ugly word.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Everyone knows the 13th Amendment fixed 75% of racism and the Civil Rights Act (of 1967 if you ask DeSantis) took care of the other 25%. Why must liberals keep rehashing the past as if history has any impact on today's world?

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

To continue to bring up the past is furthering racism. We must aspire to be colorblind. Except when it comes to judges and juries in the US District Court of the District of Columbia. Then we must fight for diversity!

Expand full comment

Gotta love that WVa diversity.

Expand full comment

A story I read this weekend about the DeSantis campaign contained the line "his controversial positions on abortion, immigration and slavery." And I have to admit it caught me off guard. Apparently, slavery is now a "controversy" that we're "debating."

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Periodic reminder that state-sponsored action destroyed Tulsa's Black Wall Street not once, but twice: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jul/18/tulsa-highway-black-wall-street

Expand full comment

“Let’s not bicker and argue about who bombed who.”

Expand full comment

Those Black people took our bullets and never gave 'em back!

Expand full comment

Just a whole lot of folks standing their ground.

Expand full comment

Well, sometimes standing other people's ground, but whatever.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

“I’m sure there’ll be an article in the Times this week about how Chris Christie and Larry Hogan are the future of the party. They never seem to catch on.” -- my longtime pet theory has been that wunderkind conservative intellectual Paul Ryan excused himself to go lurk in the weeds while the GOP Trumpwar raged, only to step fit’n’ready on the bloodied battlefield. But now I think he made a bad bet, his Nazi bona fides are too mild and long forgotten, and we shall never see a President Ryan.

Expand full comment
author

I assumed he took the money and ran. Former speakers always look happy to be out of the game (except when they go to prison for molesting children).

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Maybe. He always struck me as one of those nerds who decided at the age of 13 he was destined to be POTUS. Then he impressed some dumb people with money who don’t want to pay taxes. The DeSantis model.

Expand full comment

"Kids say the darndest things!"

-Dennis Hastert

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Oof

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

I thought this too. Although it looks like he will have a very, very long wait if that's the case.

Expand full comment

We’ll always have the time he faked working at a soup kitchen and the time he lied about his marathon finish.

Expand full comment

Ah yes. It was a more innocent time...

Expand full comment

"lied about his marathon finish"

And that was the ONLY lie he told over a whole six-hour period! How did he restrain himself?

Expand full comment

As SundayStyle says, it was a more innocent time.

Expand full comment

Paul Ryan: "I told a half-dozen lies today, and boy am I beat!"

Donald Trump: "Hold my Diet Coke..."

Expand full comment

"wunderkind conservative intellectual Paul Ryan"

It's true! He made a video where he stood in front of some charts, or graphs, or something! If that's not intellectual, what is?

Expand full comment

Don’t forget his workout photo curling weights with his baseball cap on backwards! Peggy Noonan’s heart went pit-a-pat.

Expand full comment

If he'd just remembered his "Music Band" t-shirt he'd be President now!

Expand full comment

If he understood the lyrics of his favorite band, he would have become not a Republican

Expand full comment

Like Tim Pool finding out what Machine was being Raged Against.

Expand full comment

Thanks to The Majority Report I am now aware of Tim Pool’s blighted existence. The fact that the internet enables people like him to have legions of followers is proof that Man Is Evil. /Community

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Did you know Republicans are moving away from anti-woke messaging and back to law and order while simultaneously attacking the FBI and DOJ? This is the type of cognitive dissonance you get when you let your party incise your corpus callosum so your right brain can hold a position contrary to your left brain. Toss in the equivalent of a frontal lobotomy and you have the perfect Republican voter: id-driven reactions to leaders who practice deceit and projection with the skill of a fencer wielding a broadsword.

Expand full comment

"Reprogrammable meatbags", as driftglass puts it.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023

"id-driven reactions to leaders who practice deceit and projection"

You probably already know about that constitutional amendment they're voting on tomorrow in Ohio, to raise the threshold to 60% for approval of amendments by public referendum. Naturally, all the ads on the pro-side are about children being given gender-reassignment surgery without their parent's consent.

Expand full comment

My cousin sent me an ad from her local Gettysburg area newspaper for a new Christian school. They're still pushing the story that kids across America are being allowed to "identify" as cats, and are being provided with litter boxes.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023

Notice how it's always a thing that you have to be told about through the internet because you (curiously) have never experienced the thing yourself?

Meanwhile climate change, which used to be a thing you might read scientific papers about, has become a thing people experience directly.

Expand full comment

Sweet screaming Jesus.

There was a hoopla recently over girls identifying as cats, started by a misunderstood TikTok video of a classroom argument, and then boosted into orbit by The Telegraph, the NY Post, and Tucker. There were lurid references to kids identifying as holograms or dinosaurs. Naturally nobody could ever back up these stories with evidence.

Expand full comment

Used to be little kids “identifying” as animals was called “pretending.”

Expand full comment

"Litter Boxes"

Litter boxes in the schoolroom

Litter boxes made all urine-proof

Litter boxes in the schoolroom

Litter boxes all the same

There's a pink one and a green one and a blue one and a yellow one

And they're all made completely urine-proof

And they all smell just the same

Over to you, Steve!

Expand full comment
Aug 8, 2023·edited Aug 8, 2023

Litter boxes, litter boxes,

And they're all kinda Wokey-Wacky

But I saw it on my Ticky-Tocky and it's all lies just the same

There's my cousin, and her best friend,

And she heard it from her manicurist

And she told it to the Twitteratti but it's all lies just the same

There's my landlord, on the school board,

And he heard it from Mr. Trumpty-Dumpty

And it made him all croaky-cranky but it's all lies just the same

Expand full comment

And the kittens go to cat school and then to the university

But it's down there in Florida so it's just not the same

But they all love Tony Tiger except for the really fashy ones

But you know they're always lion and they'll never be tamed

Expand full comment

There's my uncle, and his best friend

They're gonna burn down the university

Cuz their minds went all breaky-brokey

From the lies stuck in their brains

Too dark?

Expand full comment

There's DeSantis, he's a fascist

He's the guy who's all Woke-a-Dopey

And the voters all say Nopey-Nopey

And it all goes down the drain

(help me, I can't stop)

Expand full comment

"... as much as he’d like, for example, and that “historical tragedies should not be used in the service of a political agenda that has a slanted perspective on American history and the modern causes of urban blight” in reference to, get this, the Tulsa Massacre."

I have some notes for Hanania fils (taped, sans doute, across my fist): atrocities like the Tulsa Massacre were hardly terrible exceptions to the norm in the early 20th century. They actually were shamefully, horrifyingly common in the USA. Usually the scene of the crime has been concealed under a reservoir and there are an awful lot of those all over Appalachia & the South...

(The brilliant Tony Earley short story "The Prophet from Jupiter" seems to be about one of these massacre site/reservoirs.)

Expand full comment

Or the interstate highways in downtown Kansas City chopping up and demolishing Black neighborhoods.

Expand full comment

The Cross-Bronx Expressway & that big lake in Central Park come to mind as well...

Expand full comment

Or the interstate highways everywhere chopping up and demolishing Black neighborhoods.

Expand full comment

Look at the tight ring of interstate around downtown Kansas City and think, “Was this really necessary or efficient?”, and then look slightly to the south and east and see that it cuts off the Negro League Hall of Fame from downtown, as just one example.

Expand full comment

Also, the Jazz and Blues museum

Expand full comment

Indeed.

Expand full comment

One could, if one were inclined, attribute the Tulsa Massacre as leftover from Red Summer 1919: https://www.history.com/topics/black-history/chicago-race-riot-of-1919

"Usually the scene of the crime has been concealed under a reservoir and there are an awful lot of those all over Appalachia & the South..."

Lake Lanier, for example, which has developed new and improved ways of killing people as revenge.

Expand full comment

I could see a new, Woke version of Poltergeist coming out of this.

Expand full comment

Except that many of the "race riots" happened prior or much prior to 1919. East St. Louis was 1917, Wilmington was 1898.

Expand full comment

If Trump falters only Greg Abbott is hateful and cruel enough to step in. https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2023/8/5/2185513/-If-Trump-falters-only-Greg-Abbott-is-cruel-and-hateful-enough-to-step-in. With Hanaia et al as his warped brain trust.

Expand full comment

The Base grows ever bloodthirsty.

Expand full comment

Let the hate flow through you! (future Republican Presidential contender Palpatine)

Expand full comment

"I’m old, and retain dim memories of the Young Republicans of the 20th Century"

Hey, I'm old too! And what I remember about young Republicans at that time (I mean the ones who weren't working for the Nixon campaign ratfucking his opponents) was "C'mon, America's not so bad, stop being such a Grumpy Gus, OK?" A tendency which reached its peak with the performance of Up With People at the Nixon White House. So yeah, they're... um... different now.

Expand full comment

Right up to Romney, Republicans felt compelled to hold that rictus-smile attitude, "America is JUST FINE!" And then Trump came along, and it was like the uncorking of a bottle.

Expand full comment

America is already great!

Expand full comment

I have to admit, it must have been hard to hold that pose for 50 years. No wonder the dam burst when Trump came along. "Wait, we're allowed to say BAD stuff about America? This feels so liberating!"

Expand full comment

Today it would be Down With (Certain) People. I'd love to see their set list.

Expand full comment

Once you get through "Proud to be an American" and "Try that in a small town" they got nothin'.

Expand full comment

Late to the thread but....

I saw a band called "Down With People" in 1988 or thereabout. Loud angry punks having a grand time for themselves. Good enough for an encore. They played straight up versions of Pink Floyd's "Lucifer Sam" and Hank's "Cheatin' Heart". One of my better outlays of disposable income that year.

Expand full comment

I think people like Hainana and Ben Shapiro are what happens when you take 20th Century Republican youth and marinate them in a "look what you Democrats made me do" sauce

Expand full comment

I assumed they weren’t marinated, but rather incubated in vats.

Expand full comment

Yes, "marinated" sounds suspiciously ethnic. Like they might actually come out tasty.

Expand full comment

That's what Steve Bannon hopes

Expand full comment

Hey they still need some fluid in those vats

Expand full comment

"Hey, it's drier n' Mrs. Ben Shapiro in here!"

Expand full comment

Fun fact: Glenn Close got her start as a member of Up With People.

Expand full comment

Down with Sheeple!

Expand full comment

BTW, I am sitting here in the airport terminal waiting to board the flight to Chicago where we have a FOUR FREAKING HOUR layover before continuing on to Fairbanks. Keep a good thought for me as I will the plane to stay in the air 😵‍💫

Expand full comment

I have a friend who flew from L.A. to Paris. When we asked her if she slept, she said, "No. I had to help the pilot fly the plane."

Expand full comment

“And boy were my arms tired!” /rimshot

Expand full comment

I am at O'Hare at the moment, having successfully kept the plane going, and it's about 2 hours to go. Had a decent, if expensive Reuben. Saw a Lego vending machine, an apatosaur skeleton, and LACTATION POD.

Expand full comment

How strong was your lactation?

Expand full comment

I did not look inside the POD so the quality and quantity of LACTATION could not be established.

Expand full comment

Lactation seems like could be a slightly awkward point of departure.

Expand full comment

I was guessing they gave you a receipt for quantity

Expand full comment

Hey, the web address still says "Twitter". Oh, JBE Musk, you've done it again!

Expand full comment

We kid WITH you, not UPON you. More to the point we kid the POD. Not that it's a bad thing, but POD? Really?

Expand full comment

Sleeper promised us the Orgasmatron, and this is what we get.

Expand full comment

Not near as much fun anymore, what with LEDs replacing all the incandescents.

Expand full comment

Upvoted for a machine that dispenses LEGO Lactation Pods. The next Spinal Tap hit song.

Expand full comment

Now, was this a vending machine made of Lego?

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023

Only a four hour layover? Oh, you sweet summer child. Try flying from Sioux Falls to, say, London. Or better yet, have the nether lords of the airlines cancel your connecting flight on a lark, or whimsically reroute you through Atlanta or DFW.

Expand full comment

Local joke about Hartsfield-Jackson International: "If you have to go from heaven to hell you have to change planes in Atlanta."

Expand full comment

I love it when they route us 1.5 hours out of our way to change planes at a hellgate hub we were trying to avoid. If I *wanted* to fly the wrong direction to a busier airport, I would’ve scheduled it that way!

Expand full comment

Your choices are fly to a busy hub and wait or fly direct to one of a couple destinations on Allegiant. You better like it as that's what deregulation did

Expand full comment

Or Rapid City to Budapest. I had 8 hours in Heathrow and around 4 hours in Denver. It turns out Heathrow did not have TVs except in the gate areas. I did some find some Lewis Chessman replicas at the National Museum store

Expand full comment

But Rapid City, South Dakota is where James Mason & Co. depart on their trip to "the other side" in North by Northwest! Did they have to change planes in Atlanta too? When Mason says, "This is a problem best solved from a great height... over water" I didn't think he was talking about Lake Lanier.

Expand full comment

He should’ve flown Allegiant, where passengers practically have to push the plane to get it started, and you drive all the way to your destination with the blinker on.

Expand full comment

Well, the driving all the way with your blinker is just SD State Law

Expand full comment

Like perpetually driving in the left lane in Nebraska

Expand full comment

Ah, so that's why Eva Marie Saint was so desperate to not get on the plane. Allegiant: You'll prefer a climb over Washington's head to flying with us!

Expand full comment

“It’s the ONLY way to (not) fly!”

Expand full comment

Ugh. Actually though I prefer no TVs to ubiquitous Airport TV shouting at me when I just want a brief respite from noise.

Expand full comment

No TVs when you are by yourself in an airport for 8 hours kind of sucks

Expand full comment

How do so many Dipshit Centrists (h/t Atrios) and garbage people like Matthew Yglesias not only get taken seriously, but keep failing upward? Maybe credulous, dewy-eyed Ezra Klein could do a think piece about it.

Expand full comment

They literally don't have skin in the game.

Expand full comment

They assume the torch-bearing and caliper-wielding set will never come for them.

Expand full comment

"Great, I'm free to see every question as just an intoxicating intellectual exercise!"

Expand full comment

The linked Dreher piece is comedy gold. He calls Freddie de Boer a “brilliant maverick of the Left” and later plays school psychologist: “…it seems clear to me that [Hanania is on the autism spectrum], and that this has something to do with his intellectual style, and the substance of his writing. He lacks the inner sense that tells him, ‘You shouldn’t go there.’”

Yeah, about that “inner sense.” Oh, Rod…

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023

I'm sure he'll be applying that same generous spirit to the impulsive young activist who went so far as to suggest we should defund the police.

Expand full comment

Wow, only RWNJs manage to be so ableist while attempting compassion for the neurodivergent. But as neurodivergent folx are often hyper-aware of social injustice, I'd guess Dreher is as far up his own ass as ever on the question...

Expand full comment

C'mon, the poor guy has racist-Tourette's! Accommodate his disability, libs!

Expand full comment

It's the Tourette's variant where one devotes a podcast or an essay to what might be better blurted out compulsively

Expand full comment

That "spectrum" isn't autism but fascism.

Expand full comment

Now I want an Explainer that ranks all the Republican presidential candidates on the Fascism Spectrum. Just a lil' fashy or full-on fash? As usual, Trump dials it up to 11.

Expand full comment

Spinal Tap has gone digital.

Expand full comment

You know who ELSE lacked the inner sense that tells him "You shouldn't go there...."

Expand full comment

Where "there" was "Moscow in the winter"?

Expand full comment

or Moscow on July 4th

Expand full comment

Caesar crossing the Rubicon?

Expand full comment

Lamedar

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023

Hey now, Rod and Sully agree about primitive root wieners

Expand full comment

No way I'm googling

Expand full comment

I have no idea whether or not they agree. Rod had a piece in which he talked about looking over at a kid's penis while in the school bathroom. He called the black kids penis a primitive root wiener

Expand full comment

I went to college in the 60s and the Young Republicans were dicks.

Expand full comment

That's a bumper sticker.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

So I read an article in the Atlantic, "How Bronze Age Pervert Charmed the Far Right." One of the leading "edgelords" unless I'm mistaken. Being old-fashioned, I think a real intellectual strives for consistency. There's no coy "look I'm Chomsky, or maybe I'm not! Are you hip enough to 'get it?' Or are you a dowdy old square? I must obfuscate to protect myself, because I'm a brave teller-of-truth-to-power."

I'm no thinker but I've read a few things, and I've noticed that real intellectuals don't have time for this sort of nonsense. They have practical problems not shared by dilletantes, because they take in a great deal of information, criticize, synthesize. For real! Faced with confusing, complicated ideas, they value a type of earnestness. Tell them what you really think. Aim for clarity all the more because your problems may be intractable and your materials abstruse. Give yourself and your fellows at least a chance to think, for fuck's sake.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

When you don't think politics is for the solution of actual problems (like, for example, poverty or climate change) it leaves an ENORMOUS amount of time for absolute nonsense.

Expand full comment

Fascism's merely esthetic appeal to these nitwits is fathomless, but for some reason they've gotta pretend it's not just a fetish, it's the solution to everything.

Expand full comment

Army of Incels Takes Nonconsensual "Race Play" to the Streets, But It's Cool Because Choose Your Own Adventure

(Sorry folks, I think I've got a mind virus)

Expand full comment

“Army of Incels” is the worst cover version of a Björk song.

Expand full comment

I saw Army of Incels on their last tour, and it was not a very fun crowd…

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023

Somewhere they picked up the idea that politics is supposed to be about responding to people's needs and problems, but that collides with their belief that government should never, under any circumstances, help people. What results are "crises" that have to be communicated to you over YouTube because, oddly, you don't seem to experience any consequences from the supposed crisis yourself. And once politics moves from "problems I actually have" to "stuff people told me about on YouTube" the sky's the limit.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Possibly they worry politics IS about solving problems, and because they're fearful idiots, they think finding ways for the poor to have more means they themselves will get less. Like there is one pie and its size never changes -- cut a better slice for black people, that means cutting less for white people, etc. So they approach politics as an arena to introduce chaos, to ensure no solutions get done, because solutions can only hurt you.

Expand full comment

"politics as an arena to introduce chaos, to ensure no solutions get done"

And then the United States Senate steps up and says, "Is there any way I can be of help?"

Expand full comment

Shoot, Mr B – I thought you were gonna 'splain zero-sum to us again.

Expand full comment

NOBODY can explain the United States Senate.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

What I think is that they think the US is perfect, established and guided by God, and they just need to winnow out a few bad apples for everything to be Great Again. Of course, to continue the grift means constantly finding new enemies, external ones and internal ones corrupted by external ideas.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Yeah, this jives. Conservatives think they love history, but in truth what they love is mythology.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023·edited Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

I remember a video of Republican women complaining about how toys now have all these safety regulations and back in the day, they didn't have any and EVERYBODY TURNED OUT FINE. I suspect it was actually "Republican women who'd like to have fewer kids."

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Part of the appeal of Conservatism is that you already know enough to have an opinion on every topic. Before you decide whether the Goddamn gummint shoulda banned lawn Jarts, do you need to know if they were injuring 1 kid a year or a hundred or a thousand? Nah, all that "read things and learn about stuff" is just liberal elitist nonsense. God made you perfect, and Jesus loves you just the way you are.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Reading myself (very slowly as it makes me want to throw things) an article on how "the elite" have abandoned Gendah Ideology™ and it was all (or mostly, anyway) Richard Dawkins' fault. A British guy going on about how Christians have always been the peaceful preservers of culture (unlike THOSE DIRTY MUSLIMS), thus ignoring pretty much the entire 20th Century, needs a good swift kick in the tuckus. The Telegraph also has a column by Nigel Farage about how Trump needs to pick Ramaswamy as his VP, so that's the mangoes we're dealing with.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Air travel isn't annoying enough for you?

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

2 marks!

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

The fact that those Republican women voted for a misogynistic fascist rather mitigates against them turning out OK

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

A British guy going on about how Christians have always been the peaceful preservers of culture (unlike THOSE DIRTY MUSLIMS), thus ignoring pretty much the entire 20th Century

and probably the 6th to 13th Centuries

Expand full comment
Aug 8, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Centuries were made to be forgotten. That's why they made so damn many of them.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

I figured SOMEBODY would fold BAP into the comments.

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Matthew Y., quite a guy. I read a few of his economic pieces on Substack and decided he was muddled in the mind.

Too many people can't follow their own motivations. They actually believe they are engaged in rational discourse, when they are, as you say, following their desire for attention and doping their brains on rage and reactions.

People who want to win arguments are usually silly.

Expand full comment
author

Oh yeah? Well sputter sputter

Expand full comment

I heard the nutter mutter

In a voice oozing like butter

That descended into sputter

He devolved to be a rutter

Causing me to utter

"Quit pokin' me with that putter!"

Expand full comment
Aug 7, 2023Liked by Roy Edroso

Great column.

Expand full comment
author

Thx!

Expand full comment