25 Comments
⭠ Return to thread

Yep. Far too many people sputter "but...but this is AMERICA!" and think the Constitution, Declaration of Independence, and the lyrics of the national anthem operate like some kind of impenetrable force field. They don't, they're just words on paper. It requires the efforts of people to enforce those principles and keep them alive.

Expand full comment

And it helps if you read and understand the words, but that's a lot of egghead stuff.

Expand full comment

I am once again begging every American to watch the 2001 film "Conspiracy" starring Ken Branagh and Colin Firth. The law -- the words on paper -- can be changed in one meeting when there are complicit judges who will give those new laws the nod.

Expand full comment

I can name at least two of the judges.

Expand full comment

The German version of the film is called "The Wannsee Conference". Germans being studious record keepers, much of the dialogue is straight from the minutes of the actual meeting.

I watched it again a while back and was struck by the sheer banality of the administrative planning for mass murder. (Boy, did Ms. Arendt get that one right!)

The most interesting choice the producers made was the character of the stenographer. A pert, efficient gal-Friday who occasionally interrupts the proceedings to ask for clarification. At one point, one of the more earthy Nazis goes on an obscenity-laden tirade, much to the displeasure of Reinhard Heydrich. One does not use such language in the presence of a young lady!

Expand full comment

Said Trump's supporters: "I do Nazi, but I Wannsee."

Expand full comment

2 marks: 1.5 for Crude, 0.5 for Effective.

Expand full comment

One has to be principled when one is planning the most efficient mass murder, after all.

Expand full comment

Oddly enough, if you actually read stuff about fascism, you see the parallels! Wild.

Expand full comment

The Guardrails(TM) will hold. And then we shall all to brunch.

Expand full comment

[whispers] don't look now but at least half of the guardrails are already gone and they are busily working on disassembling the rest.

Expand full comment

[Dick Durbin forlornly averts his eyes]

Expand full comment

Susan Collins says its regrettable, but they've learned their lesson.

Expand full comment

I know, that horrible woman Kamala Harris is threatening to dismantle the greatest protection for democracy the world has ever known, I speak, of course, of the filibuster.

Expand full comment

[Recoils in horror] not the Holy Grail!

Expand full comment

The requirement that 60 Senators vote to allow a bill to come to a vote is the greatest protection against majority rule that we have.

Expand full comment

Well, the filibuster and the electoral college are the two greatest protections against majority rule that we have.

I mean the filibuster, the electoral college, the two-senators-per-state rule, the cap on the House at 435...

I'll come in again.

AMONG the greatest protections against majority rule we have are such diverse elements AS...

Expand full comment

Interesting how our slave-rapin' Founders had such a fear of majority rule that they felt the need to build in so many safeguards against it.

Expand full comment

Only 2 of those were present at the Constitution. The filibuster was not adopted in the Senate until 1806 and not used until 1837. The current filibuster rules were adopted in like the 1980s ar 1990s. The 435 member House was adopted in 1929

Expand full comment

As it is a Senate Rule, she has no ability to do anything but recommend to the Senators to dismantle

Expand full comment

Nevertheless, Joe Manchin is OUTRAGED that this uppity woman, a US Senator herself, should have an opinion on the subject.

Expand full comment

Also it’s helpful for them to forget that the Nuremberg Laws were literally taken from Jim Crow legislation, Zyklon-B was first used on Latine border crossers, & the America First movement sprung up around the same time as Nazi takeover.

Expand full comment

Coincidentally, NONE of the above are jack-booted. Jackboots are for show – wingtips are for go.

And in that vein, there's Mussolini's old standby definition. Fascism is Corporatism.

Expand full comment

Also have seen more than a few "Person in the street" interviews where our fellow Americans say it might be time to suspend the Constitution -- just for four years, so we can really "solve our problems."

Expand full comment

Sure, what we need is a strongman, who can solve all our problems (and especially the brown-skinned ones) unfettered by rules or laws or the need to vote on stuff.

There should be a name for that sort of thing.

Expand full comment