184 Comments

Amen, brother.

Expand full comment

… is the most sampled drum break in musical history.

Expand full comment

Despite all the free time on my hands, I've neglected (or chose not) to ascertain the actual definition of fascism. More: I'm copping out and leave the issue as an anti-democratic state--whether in form or just function--that has, like, a siamese twin, symbiotic relationship with capitalists. A circle jerk, if I may. Not an orthodox definition IIRC but works for me.

Anyway vis a vis the masses: Not sure at all the word is relevant or useful in any way (no matter how defined, of course). Every descriptions of fascist policies, at least superficial definitions. Of course if there's a huge problem involving illegal immigrants, of course the problem should be addressed and said persons sent back home. But that's one huge if there. But on the surface, where the mainstream news media leave it as a rule, Trump's policy doesn't look as bad as it of course is. The core is being (willfully) ignored by our exceptional media; they choose to accept there's a problem.

I'm losing my focus and thread but there's that circle jerk: reporters' bosses' preferred candidate claims there's a problem and offers an extreme, vulgar solution and press chooses not to criticize or critique it thereby legitimatizing it.

So calling Donnie fash works for us parlor trick (h/t H Kurtzman) nerds but the little people? Please. Does the word have any meaning for them? Do they even remember anything about the Nazis beyond the fact that they were the big bads in WWII?

Personally, my preference is maybe just calling them scum. Simpler word with universal understanding. Fascist opens a can of worms requiring talmudic-level study.

Expand full comment

More accurately "the big bads in WWII movies".

Expand full comment

If you want to go history-wise, then the Nazis were far more the USSR's enemy than ours.

Too, the Nazis are, in the minds of the little people, the big bads. Of course, Wall Street always had a thing for them which apparently never fully died out.

As for the movies, histories of wars and the US are insanely detached from reality, relying on the barest minimum of facts, if that.

Expand full comment

@KanekoaTheGreat

JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon: "If you do not control the borders, you are going to destroy our country...

Now that they are sending migrants into New York... all my super liberal friends realize what a problem it is."

Migrants. In New York!!!!

Expand full comment

Why, I hear there's this one neighborhood in New York City where things have gotten so out of control you wouldn't even know you were in America! Have to admit that I do like the Moo-Shu Pork, though.

Expand full comment

Migrants! Like the pusher of booze/pimp, Her Drumpf with the awful genes! Or like the Scot girl who came to America to nail a monied husband.

Clearly, letting bad people into the nation is a very old problem even if we're a nation of immigrants...

Expand full comment

Plus, now your Mayor has been indicted so there is no one left to resist the dusky hoards

Expand full comment

Fascist is Italian for "belligerent asshole"

Expand full comment

Even I know that’s not the correct definition but it works for me 😉

It’s wrong yet universal…

Expand full comment

Defining "fascism" can be a slippery thing, primarily because they're political chameleons. If a policy gets them results now, they'll advocate it, and then toss it when it gets inconvenient. Nazis are different from Italian Fascisti are different from Falangists are different from Atomwaffen.

Expand full comment

The money empowers the thugs to serve the monied people yet more.

The nuts and bolts stuff is whatever works in the moment. No more principle than that.

Expand full comment

Fascism has a notoriously hazy definition, even among those who study it as a career. This was a central point in many blogs and stories during the reign of the Orange King, when people were trying to make sense of what the fuck is he even doing, and fascist was a good first approximation. The Boss is cutting to the chase here, its Nazi shit pure and simple. People are assuming that label has a similar weight as "racist", but I dunno. There's only a handful of people who lived through that shitshow, and Republicans are simply ignoring the word. Since they are only talking to their base, and their base doesn't concern itself with abstractions like Nazi or fascist, its up to our savior, The Independent Voter, to come to our rescue. Again.

Expand full comment

I always direct people to Umberto Eco's "Ur Fascism" https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/umberto-eco-ur-fascism

Expand full comment

Just read it! I’m sold on Eco’s definition. He nails the case.

Expand full comment

This is another banger, Roy.

Got to love the guy who said Trump wasn’t a fascist although he was “using fascist political tactics.” So I guess if I lift that guy’s wallet, he’ll accuse me of using the tactics of larceny, but he won’t call me a thief, right? These Milquetoasts and hair-splitters can fuck all the way off.

And yeah, some people won’t acknowledge the truth until they’ve been thrown in the back of a van. It’s a variation of leopards/faces: “I never thought all those fascist political tactics would produce a fascist police state.”

Expand full comment

Roberts Rules of Hitler is a keeper. I can picture the morning editorial meeting: “Should we capitalize nazi when we’re just talking about Trump’s young fans on 8chan?”

Expand full comment

"Who brought their German to English dictionary?"

Expand full comment

I speak jive, does that count?

Expand full comment

What constitutes a quorum for our Nazi debate? And did we get a second for the motion on the floor? No? A motion to table the discussion for later? Seconded? All in favor? Motion carried. Next order of business: Is protesting literal genocide rude and upsetting?

Expand full comment

Yeah, Donnie not only wants to deport the nieblankes "flooding America" (I can barely get to the garage for all the migrants standing in the driveway!*) but wants to evict the foreign students involved in the college protests.

* I mistyped "farage" here - an apt mistake.

Expand full comment

I wondered why Nigel got a tingle...

Expand full comment

Oh, I'm makin' plans for Nigel. Specifically, the plan is to drop him and JD Vance off in downtown Port Au Prince without any money or identification and see if they can find their way home.

Expand full comment

And Prince, dead all these years, unable to help...

Expand full comment

Sitting their in their Safe European Home. Way to go

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1xgwXkULDCs

Expand full comment

For way too many people, it simply CAN'T be fascism unless there are goose-stepping goons in Hugo Boss uniforms parading through the streets and giving stiff-arm salutes.

And even then, they might characterize it as celebrating heritage, not hate.

Expand full comment

Yep. Far too many people sputter "but...but this is AMERICA!" and think the Constitution, Declaration of Independence, and the lyrics of the national anthem operate like some kind of impenetrable force field. They don't, they're just words on paper. It requires the efforts of people to enforce those principles and keep them alive.

Expand full comment

And it helps if you read and understand the words, but that's a lot of egghead stuff.

Expand full comment

I am once again begging every American to watch the 2001 film "Conspiracy" starring Ken Branagh and Colin Firth. The law -- the words on paper -- can be changed in one meeting when there are complicit judges who will give those new laws the nod.

Expand full comment

I can name at least two of the judges.

Expand full comment

The German version of the film is called "The Wannsee Conference". Germans being studious record keepers, much of the dialogue is straight from the minutes of the actual meeting.

I watched it again a while back and was struck by the sheer banality of the administrative planning for mass murder. (Boy, did Ms. Arendt get that one right!)

The most interesting choice the producers made was the character of the stenographer. A pert, efficient gal-Friday who occasionally interrupts the proceedings to ask for clarification. At one point, one of the more earthy Nazis goes on an obscenity-laden tirade, much to the displeasure of Reinhard Heydrich. One does not use such language in the presence of a young lady!

Expand full comment

Said Trump's supporters: "I do Nazi, but I Wannsee."

Expand full comment

One has to be principled when one is planning the most efficient mass murder, after all.

Expand full comment

Oddly enough, if you actually read stuff about fascism, you see the parallels! Wild.

Expand full comment

The Guardrails(TM) will hold. And then we shall all to brunch.

Expand full comment

[whispers] don't look now but at least half of the guardrails are already gone and they are busily working on disassembling the rest.

Expand full comment

[Dick Durbin forlornly averts his eyes]

Expand full comment

Susan Collins says its regrettable, but they've learned their lesson.

Expand full comment

I know, that horrible woman Kamala Harris is threatening to dismantle the greatest protection for democracy the world has ever known, I speak, of course, of the filibuster.

Expand full comment

[Recoils in horror] not the Holy Grail!

Expand full comment

As it is a Senate Rule, she has no ability to do anything but recommend to the Senators to dismantle

Expand full comment

Also it’s helpful for them to forget that the Nuremberg Laws were literally taken from Jim Crow legislation, Zyklon-B was first used on Latine border crossers, & the America First movement sprung up around the same time as Nazi takeover.

Expand full comment

Coincidentally, NONE of the above are jack-booted. Jackboots are for show – wingtips are for go.

And in that vein, there's Mussolini's old standby definition. Fascism is Corporatism.

Expand full comment

Also have seen more than a few "Person in the street" interviews where our fellow Americans say it might be time to suspend the Constitution -- just for four years, so we can really "solve our problems."

Expand full comment

Sure, what we need is a strongman, who can solve all our problems (and especially the brown-skinned ones) unfettered by rules or laws or the need to vote on stuff.

There should be a name for that sort of thing.

Expand full comment

They say this about white supremacists as well. Not bald & in red bracers? No Klan robes? Well then you must be “racially-tinged.”

Perhaps I could suggest, “Served with a racist reduction & facist drizzle, as well as roast new potatoes.”

Expand full comment

It's not white supremacy without the Klan robes, it's only sparkling authoritarianism with a soupçon of racially-charged rhetoric.

Expand full comment

Don't forget to add a twist of Economic Anxiety!

Expand full comment

Served on Klean-Klan Linen table settings.

Expand full comment

Hearted, but I was hoping this place would not degrade into a recipe blog...

I HATE to cook.

Expand full comment

As Roy said, when they're in the back of a police van maybe they'll say, hey, I think there's fascism afoot.

Expand full comment

Fine people on both sides.

Expand full comment

Oh my heavens! (Flaps hands rapidly in front of face) You are so *shrill* Roy Edroso! Why, you’re almost as bad as that nasty Clinton woman with her deplorables and all. If you can’t learn to speak civilly I will have to insist on seeing a manager!

Expand full comment

I went with Nasty, Noxious or Nincompoop. Oh and Numbnuts.

Do the "B word" next !

When you got some guy named Dylan writing for some online news source (excuse me - "media conglomerate")with some made up word (Politico), or some Latin word(vox) or some real word that the spelled wrong ( "semafor"? What the fuck?) as a name most likely the article is bullshit.

Especially if the media conglomerate has ever had anything to do with that hack Ezra Klein.

Instead of tattoos I think they'll try and chip the migrants like they do dogs. Leon Musk will get the contract for 6,200 bucks per person. That puts the bill for 20 million migrants somewhere north of 124 billion dollars and that ain't cheese! Coincidentally, the Super PAC Leon setup for this election will pay Melania $450,000 a month to give a monthly speech to new hires at Tesla.

Expand full comment

What else could he have meant with the "serial numbers"? I'm sure every legal immigrant has some kind of file, which is no doubt identified by a number already. Wonder where Melania's serial number would go.

Expand full comment

Good point, the legal immigrants would be MUCH more easy to round up than the illegal ones. And, given that Tubby is profoundly lazy and wants fast, fast results with minimal effort, that's what he'd do.

Expand full comment

Yup. In lieu of a social security number there is a Tax Identification Number (TIN). Which means that legal immigrants ARE PAYING TAXES. Not that this matters to Nazis.

Expand full comment

Only if the employer is following the law. Which seems unlikely since they are hiring people that are not supposed to work

Expand full comment

That ^^ is the sort of wondering I try mightily to avoid, but I'm glad SOMEBODY does it...

Expand full comment

You know on their social platforms, when described as Nazis, these Nazis complain that others are calling them “the N-word.” Which makes me want to park a 1953 Oldsmobile right between their upper & lower palate.

Expand full comment

Damn! Another Hitler reference!

Expand full comment

I always refer to "Semafor" as translated from Russian, because that's likely where the money comes from.

Expand full comment

I would have thought Elmo would have charged 14,880 per person.

Expand full comment

They are indeed. And they need to be treated as such.

Expand full comment

[Wow — I just posted Roy's essay on FB and it was booted off in less than a minute!] But I will do it again —

Expand full comment

using the hashtag “whitesupremacy” on TikTok will get the offending language auto-removed.

Expand full comment

REBID gets results! Let me try.

Expand full comment

II heard that slogan read in the voice of John Madden holding up a tube of athlete’s foot cream.

Expand full comment

Ha ha they blocked me too. What a bunch of squares!

Expand full comment

Dorks!

Expand full comment

Well, I'll be damned: I objected and FB restored Roy's essay! https://www.facebook.com/robin.cisne/

Expand full comment

Now you take back all those mean things you said about Mr. Zuckerberg.

Expand full comment

Hmmm...tricky that...

Expand full comment

[Marvel supervillain voice] NEVER!

Expand full comment

You're getting all Meta

Expand full comment

"though he didn’t say whether these would be tattooed on their arms."

Under the New Regime, the numbers will be laser-printed on their retinas.

Expand full comment

And this policy will be pushed by the exact same people who rave about the government forcing everybody to wear the Number of the Beast in order to buy or sell at market.

Expand full comment

Everyone will be happy if we let the states decide!

Expand full comment

I will never understand how the Let the States Decide crowd believes that is more responsive than the federal Let the Individuals Decide policy... ohhhh unless it isn't about anything except being the little tinpot dictator of all the pretty girls.

Expand full comment

Ah, but your Social Security number is used to give you government BENEFITS. See the difference? As long as you're HURTING people, number away!

Expand full comment

Don't tell them, but those numbers? They're Arabic!

Expand full comment

The more u know...

Expand full comment

Before the Arabs, I knew nothing. Since the Arabs, I know zero.

Expand full comment

Correction: You didn't know nothing

Expand full comment

I sit* corrected.

*Woulda filed a brief on my behalf but the court ruled I don't have standing...whaddya gonna do, amiright?

Expand full comment

I thought Bern was doing Sergeant Schulze

Expand full comment

I ask the NYT et al: is Fascist Wannabe so much better?

Expand full comment

Not bad, actually. These Junior 88's aspire higher.

Expand full comment

Do we usually draw a big moral distinction between "rapist" and "attempted rapist"?

Expand full comment

I say, good sir, this is editorializing at its most intemperate, recklessly raising the temperature of the water in which all of us frogs are boiling.

PS) It chaps my taint that Fash rhetoric has made most commentators & pols accept the Nazi premise that undocumented immigrants don’t deserve social or legal protections. “Of course I want to protect _legal_ immigration,” they’ll say, desperate to have you believe they’re _reasonable_ for cripe’s sake. As if crossing some shitty border makes one the worst kind of criminal, surely deserving to be brutalized, separated from one’s family (still going on, y’know), exploited, trafficked, what have you. “Of course I don’t condone Herr President Trump’s new initiative of hanging the naked, dead bodies of border crossers on the outside of His Glorious Border Wall as deterrent. I prefer burying the slaughtered in unmarked mass graves near the wall, which as all onlookers will note, is a _much more_ moderate position,” these liberal chud-fucks will say in the near future.

Expand full comment

Is this before or after they demand landmining the border?

Expand full comment

Liberals would demand the crocodiles in the border moat be vaccinated against COVID...

Expand full comment

I let in a few, but they got uppity so I demoated them...

Expand full comment

The US Constitution does not distinguish between citizens and non-citizens with respect to their rights

Expand full comment

Tell that to the Fascists, or the liberals who have already ceded so much ground to them...

Expand full comment

MSNBC's Alex Wagner was in Michigan talking with idiots about the election. Younger men were leaning toward Trump. Union guys. These are low info voters. If I were not a dispassionate scientist, I would deport them all.

Since I am neither dispassionate nor a scientist, except when watching cable news, I shall take no such extreme action.

On the other hand, no one seems to have a problem or even question calling Democrats commies. Let's talk about that.

Red baiting and anticommunism are a religion still in the US. I call BS.

Expand full comment

Did they say THE ECONOMY?

Expand full comment

I don't have a fucking clue when it comes to football, but if I was forced to rank all the positions on a football team in order of importance, I guess I'd start with "Quarterback"? Yeah, nobody can fault me for that choice, whew, I almost looked stupid there.

Expand full comment

I dunno...the guy who lets the QB stick two hands up his butt must be worth a sympathy vote...

Expand full comment

Ah, but what's he called? I wouldn't want to give away that I don't know anything beyond "Quarterback." Nope, I'm staying with the safe choice here.

Expand full comment

I'm told there used to be a saying among business types, "Nobody ever got fired for buying IBM." Updating to today's polling: "Nobody ever got looked-at funny for saying 'The Economy'"

Expand full comment

The butt hands guy is the Center

Expand full comment

He who cannot hold.

Expand full comment

Parody song: Rush Limbaugh sings “I’m a Nazi”

https://youtu.be/gq7nxvAPS-c?feature=shared

This just in: Rush Limbaugh is still dead. /SNL

Expand full comment

I first saw that when Bartcop linked to it back in the day. Boy, remember Bartcop? Those were the days.

Expand full comment

Tequila and Shirley Manson (Garbage).

Expand full comment

I heard Randi Rhodes play it on her show.

Expand full comment

I used to have all the lyrics memorized!

Expand full comment

Word.

Expand full comment

Most excellent piece, Mr. Edroso

Expand full comment

From you, that's gold! Thanks.

Expand full comment

Vox, 2020: "using fascist political tactics"

NYT, 1922: "... several reliable, well-informed sources confirmed the idea that Hitler's anti-Semitism was not so genuine or violent as it sounded, and that he was merely using anti-Semitic propaganda as a bait to catch masses of followers and keep them aroused, enthusiastic, and in line for the time when his organization is perfected and sufficiently powerful to be employed effectively for political purposes."

Expand full comment

“… to enact said anti-semitic policies.”

Expand full comment

One wonders what political purposes the 1922 NYT believed would be pursued by a party kept aroused and enthusiastic by anti-Semitism.

The NYT seems to have a real hard time then and now calling a shovel a shovel. If a big chunk of the American electorate supports a convict who sicced a violent mob on vote-certifying to stay in power while lying outright that he won the election, is currently planning to steal the next election, and has announced intent to rule as a dictator on behalf of racists and neanderthal theologians, the headline is never justifiably "Perhaps these people mean well."

I'd like to see "One quarter of Americans are fascists: Why, and how to fix them," but I'd settle for "Trump is a fascist and Republicans choose to empower him."

Expand full comment

Maggie Haberman shakes a stern finger at you for "undermining faith" in the press.

Expand full comment

Hmmm... makes you wonder Whose Side They're Really On...

Expand full comment

The NYT is on the side of their money and Trump running close brings in the money

Expand full comment